Should we continue to allow this type of punishment in our public schools? This question has raised the eyebrows of many people including teachers, parents, religious groups, and psychologists around the world.
Surprisingly, there are only two industrialized countries that allow this type of punishment in their public schools McCarthy Corporal punishment is controversial in many ways. For instance, many Christians argue that the physical discipline of a child is perfectly acceptable and withholding that can be detrimental to the child.
The Christian faith and conservative Jews believe that by not punishing the child, he will become spoiled, and therefore less healthy. Physical punishment also raises the issue of constitutional rights.
These amendment issues can be interpreted many different ways so the federal court decided to let the states handle this issue under the provision of state laws McCarthy However, excessive force does not constitute as reasonable punishment and is prohibited by federal law. There are not too many people who remain neutral on this position; however, government is working hard to regulate it. In April of , the Public Health Study Commission of North Carolina approved a recommendation that clarifies corporal punishment policies in schools. They are also required to have a qualified teacher or administrator present, and must notify the parent of any punishment that takes place.
These regulations make it more difficult to use unnecessary force and less dangerous for the child by preventing serious physical harm.
Custom Writing Service - Professional Essay Writing Help of A+ Quality
Teachers believe for this to be so effective because it is fast and efficient. Many teachers and educators believe that it is the only way. Not only is it fast and effective, but it backs up their limits when their boundaries are crossed. Teachers are not the only ones who support this type of punishment. It extends to the parents of the children as well.
- Essay On Corporal Punishment Is A Crime Against Students.
- All You Want to Know About Corporal Punishment | UNICEF.
- Essay Corporal Punishment and Children;
- thesis construction bridge span by span;
- Essay on Corporal Punishment?
- Corporal punishment.
- college assignment help writing.
Many parents who use this type of punishment in their homes actually prefer it to be utilized at school. They believe that their children do not respond to verbal warnings or lighter punishment hence the sharp stimulus being the only way. However, with the awareness of new science and research studies, more parents are becoming opposed of it. Parents are becoming more concerned about the emotional effects corporal punishment has on their children. More parents are accepting this view.
In the U. Want to know the price of your unique Paper? Get a Price. A limited time offer! Get custom essay sample written according to your requirements. Corporal Punishment in Public Schools. See id , at See Nelson v.
Corporal Punishment Essay
Heyne , F. Turman , F.
- good thesis statement autobiography.
- das schreiben von essays.
- ny times essay contest modern love.
- early american essayists;
See also, Santana v. Collazo , F. The American Correctional Association has also issued standards banning use of corporal punishment in juvenile facilities.
See also Steven J. In addition, corporal punishment and other harsh disciplinary practices are prohibited in publicly-funded non-medical substance abuse and long-term medical care facilities. See, e. See also A Violent Education, at 5 "In the same year , in the 13 states with the highest rates of paddling, 1. Although girls of all races were paddled less than boys, African American girls were nonetheless physically punished at more than twice the rate of their white counterparts in those 13 states during this period".
See Civil Rights Data Collection, supra note 1. May 22, Adolescent Health , The American Academy of Pediatrics has noted that "corporal punishment may adversely affect a student's self-image and school achievement and it may contribute to disruptive and violent behavior. Skip to main content. Help us continue to fight human rights abuses. Please give now to support our work.
Introduction Dear Chairperson McCarthy, Ranking Member Platts, and Members of the Subcommittee: On behalf of the American Civil Liberties Union ACLU , its over half a million members, countless additional supporters and activists, and fifty-three affiliates nationwide and Human Rights Watch, one of the world's leading independent organizations dedicated to defending and protecting human rights, we applaud the House Education and Labor Subcommittee on Healthy Families and Communities for conducting a hearing concerning the ongoing corporal punishment of American public school children and its impact on their educational success.
The Ongoing Use of Corporal Punishment in Public Schools Each year, hundreds of thousands of students are subjected to corporal punishment in public schools.
The Disproportionate Use of Corporal Punishment Students of color and students with disabilities are disproportionately subjected to corporal punishment, hampering their access to a supportive learning environment. I would say out of the whole school there's only about three white kids who have gotten paddled.
Even with all black students, there is an imbalance: darker-skinned students get worse punishment. This really affected me, being a dark-skinned person myself. In Impairing Education , parents and grandparents of students with disabilities noted the changes in behavior and barriers to educational achievement stemming from the use of corporal punishment: A grandmother of a student who has Asperger's syndrome withdrew him from his Oklahoma school in part because of the hostile environment stemming from frequent use of corporal punishment: "It made him much more introverted.
He very much didn't want to go to school. No one's supposed to go to school to be tortured, school is supposed to be fun. Now, he struggles with anger; right after the incidents he'd have anger explosions. The Impact of Corporal Punishment On Students' Academic Performance Harsh physical punishments do not improve students' in-school behavior or academic performance.